Winckler & Harvey, L.L.P.
A Medical Malpractice and Personal Injury Law Firm
Free Initial Consultations 512-593-7399

Parental knowledge of risks to baby is important before procedure

Texas childbirth comes with risks to both mother and baby. Sometimes, those risks are due to less-than-ideal pre-natal care. Other times, it is the result of medical malpractice by the delivering doctor. It may arise because of information a physician does not share with the patient or how the doctor performed the intended procedure.

Baby's arm permanently injured in childbirth

As reported by USA Today, an obstetrician was the defendant in a lawsuit that alleged that he forcefully pulled a baby from the birth canal when its shoulder was stuck and preventing it from birth. The plaintiff's argument was that the doctor pulled too hard on the baby, which caused the baby to suffer a permanently paralyzed arm due to nerve damage.

Specifically, the action tore two of the baby's five nerves in his shoulder in half. The remaining nerves endured such severe stretching that they were no longer operational.

A lifetime of physical limitations

While subsequent surgeries helped increase the arm's functioning, the now nine-year-old has many limitations. He cannot ride a bike due to the result on his wrist, which curls inward and makes him unable to steer. His arm is unable to reach his stomach, nor the back of his head, which makes him less competitive in his soccer activities. He has difficulty zipping up his pants. At rest, his fingers uncontrollably twitch and his injured harm is a few inches shorter than the other.

Failure to disclose risks of procedure to remove baby

In addition to the excess force the doctor used when pulling on the baby, the lawsuit also asserted that the physician failed to disclose to the parent the risks involved in trying to free the baby in that manner. Arguably, the parent could not fully consent to this form of birthing if she was unaware of the risks to the baby. Perhaps, had the parent known, she would have chosen another option if one was available, such as C-section.

A $3,000,000 verdict

The defense argued that the damage to the baby was the result of natural maternal forces. However, the jury returned a three-million-dollar verdict against the doctor. It was unclear if this suit would affect the doctor's license.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information
Email Us For A Response

Want To
Learn More?

At Winckler & Harvey, LLP, we are committed to giving every individual and family we represent the attention they deserve, delivered with the highest caliber of knowledge and skill available. Do not hesitate to get the representation you need.
Email or call us at 512-593-7399.

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy

Lawyers Trusted In Texas And Nationwide

Members of our team have received many honors and awards.

  • Best Lawyers | Best Law Firms
  • Best Lawyers in America
  • Best Lawyers | 2017
  • Best Lawyers of the year
  • Best Law Firms and Best Lawyers in America is a Woodward White Peer-Review Publication
    Our firm has earned the designation of Best Law Firms since 2010
    Jay Winckler has been designated a Best Lawyer since 2009
    Jay Harvey has been designated a Best Lawyer since 2006
  • Super Lawyers (A service of Thomson Reuters)
    Jay Winckler: 2003, 2011-2012, 2014-2017
    Jay Harvey: 2003 - 2017