We Fight for You
Photo of professionals at Winckler & Harvey PLLC

AI in healthcare: Who’s responsible when AI makes a mistake?

On Behalf of | Jun 17, 2024 | Medical Malpractice

Artificial Intelligence (AI) is becoming more important in healthcare. Doctors and hospitals use AI to help diagnose diseases and plan treatments. These systems analyze lots of data quickly, like medical images and patient records, and give suggestions to doctors. This helps speed up the process and ensures doctors catch important details.

However, there is a growing concern about who is responsible when AI makes a mistake. If an AI system gives a wrong diagnosis or suggests a treatment that doesn’t work, who is to blame? This question is important because errors in healthcare can have serious consequences.

Human vs. AI accountability

When a human doctor makes a mistake, there are established rules and systems for accountability. They can be held responsible through medical boards and malpractice lawsuits. However, with AI, the situation is more complex. AI systems are developed by teams of programmers and data scientists, and they learn from vast amounts of data. If an AI makes a mistake, determining who is at fault—whether it’s the creators, the doctors using the AI, or the hospitals purchasing the systems—becomes unclear.

Potential solutions

One solution could be to require doctors to always review AI recommendations before making decisions based on them. This ensures that human judgment remains the final authority. Yet, challenges persist. Can doctors consistently identify errors made by AI? Moreover, what happens if the AI makes a mistake that isn’t easily noticeable to a human?

The need for regulations

To address these concerns, there must be strict regulations for AI in healthcare. These regulations should include thorough testing of AI systems before they are used in hospitals, and continuous monitoring to catch any problems early. Additionally, there should be guidelines to determine who is responsible if an AI system makes an error.

Finding the balance

AI has great potential to improve healthcare, but it is crucial to address these accountability issues to ensure patient safety. By finding the right balance, doctors can harness the power of AI while protecting patients from harm.

FindLaw Network